ESS IA example: recycling data and investigation planning
Work through simulated ESS IA recycling data, then use a documented cafeteria case to explain how competing priorities can affect a waste strategy.

Identify the environmental issue and measurable question
Choose a local issue you can investigate with accessible evidence. Define the site, period and response before selecting a method. An illustrative question might compare the proportion of incorrectly sorted items at permitted school recycling stations under different signage conditions. Specify what counts as an item and how sorting will be classified.
The example requires school permission and a suitable observation method. Do not handle waste or collect identifiable information without arrangements approved by the school. Discuss what evidence can address the question within the available time.
Keep the system and strategy connected
ESS combines environmental systems with societal perspectives. In the course first assessed in 2026, the investigation includes attention to perspectives affecting a strategy related to the issue. Identify a strategy that already exists or is being developed to address the issue. Discuss its link to your question with your teacher and find evidence for the perspectives you plan to compare.
A documented cafeteria sorting programme could link a school waste investigation to the wider problem of incorrectly sorted waste. Students, facilities staff and administrators may value convenience, reliable classification, cost and waste reduction differently. Investigate those perspectives appropriately instead of assuming what each group thinks.
Design a comparable observation
Define the sampling unit, observation period, location and classification rules. A proportion of incorrectly sorted items requires both a numerator and a meaningful denominator. Compare similar contexts where possible, such as equivalent periods and stations with comparable use. Record conditions that could influence the result.
If signage conditions differ alongside station location and traffic, you cannot readily attribute a difference to signage alone. You might narrow the question to a comparison, improve the design or qualify the eventual conclusion. Choose the option the evidence and permissions make feasible.
Pilot the ambiguous part
Try a small approved observation to test whether classifications are clear and data can be collected consistently. Where a method involves judging categories, check how two observers interpret the same classification guidance without compromising the student's individual work. Resolve ambiguous categories before the main collection.
Record the pilot and method changes. Consider whether the observation period captures meaningful variation or only an unusual event. A workable sampling plan balances comparability, coverage and the school timetable.
Plan the analysis and perspective evidence
Decide how you will calculate proportions, compare conditions and represent variation. Keep raw observations and contextual records. Choose methods you can explain and that suit your data. Distinguish evidence about sorting outcomes from evidence about stakeholder preferences; each supports a different part of the investigation.
- Use a consistent definition of the measured outcome.
- Document access, sampling and classification decisions.
- Support perspective claims with appropriate evidence.
- Explain tensions that could affect the strategy's outcomes.
ESS IA example: why the overall percentage can reverse
The recycling question above needs more than a total number of incorrectly sorted items. This short example shows how the mix of locations can change a comparison, even when each percentage is calculated correctly.
All counts are simulated. A and B represent two signage conditions at two fictional school recycling stations. No observations, interviews or intervention were carried out. The example teaches an analysis decision; it is not a complete IA, a recommended sample size or a study assigned a mark.
1. Keep the numerator with its denominator
The outcome is the percentage of classified items that are incorrectly sorted: incorrectly sorted items ÷ all classified items × 100. Counts are numbers of items, and the calculated outcome is a percentage. A real investigation must define the classification rules and handle ambiguous items consistently.
On a small screen, swipe inside the table. Each row is a signage–station group, not an independent experiment for every item.
| Signage · station | Incorrectly sorted (items) | All classified (items) | Incorrectly sorted (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A · Canteen | 30 | 100 | 30.0% |
| A · Library | 4 | 200 | 2.0% |
| B · Canteen | 50 | 200 | 25.0% |
| B · Library | 1 | 100 | 1.0% |
2. Compare the pooled and station-level results
All observed items pooled
A: (30 + 4) ÷ (100 + 200) × 100
B: (50 + 1) ÷ (200 + 100) × 100
11.3% → 17.0%The pooled proportion is about 5.7 percentage points higher under B.
Compare each station separately
Canteen: 30.0% under A → 25.0% under B.
Library: 2.0% under A → 1.0% under B.
Both are lower under BThe descriptive direction reverses when the two locations are pooled.
Why? The canteen has the higher incorrect-sorting proportion in both conditions. It contributes one third of A’s observed items but two thirds of B’s. The totals therefore combine the locations with different weights. Neither the pooled arithmetic nor the separate percentages establish that changing signs caused an improvement or a decline.
3. Make the limitation change the next step
A defensible reading: the invented records show a different location mix between signage conditions. Compare like contexts and investigate traffic, timing, item types and classification before attributing the pattern to the signs.
A useful check: one additional item classified as incorrect in Library B would change 1/100 to 2/100, matching Library A’s 2%. This sensitivity matters more than displaying several extra decimal places.
For a real, approved study, plan comparable observation periods and retain results by station and period. If signs are assigned to whole station-periods, individual items do not become independent treatment units. The four groups here contain no information about variation between periods, random allocation or a suitable inferential test. Stratifying by location addresses the mixing problem; it cannot remove every other confounder.
Also keep the environmental claim proportional to the measure. Counting items does not measure their mass, the amount ultimately recycled or an emissions saving. Those questions need additional evidence about materials and the waste system.
4. Connect the analysis to a strategy and perspectives
In the ESS course first assessed in 2026, the strategy discussion considers how tensions between perspectives can affect outcomes. The counts above cannot establish anyone’s priorities. One possible tension to investigate is between detailed sorting instructions and ease of use; another concerns the resources needed to maintain signs. These are questions to check, not views to assign to students or staff.
Use relevant local evidence, such as the actual signage, permitted feedback or documented resource needs, and explain how the tension could affect the strategy. Keep that evidence distinct from the measured sorting outcome. See the official ESS guide, internal assessment guidance, for the requirements applicable to your session.
Explain a tension in a real waste strategy
The earlier sorting counts are simulated. This separate exercise uses a documented strategy. A 2014 report describes how two Minnetonka middle schools in Minnesota introduced reusable utensils and bowls alongside redesigned cafeteria sorting stations and student education. The strategy addressed disposable food ware waste and gave students a way to return reusables while separating trash, recycling and food scraps. Read the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency case study, especially printed pages 3, 6 and 10.
- What the project team wanted to achieve
- Keep reusable utensils and bowls in circulation and keep different waste streams apart. The new station asked students to sort waste first, then return utensils and bowls. Adults helped students use the stations during the first week.
- What lunchtime operations had to accommodate
- A station at Minnetonka Middle School East did not fit the cafeteria’s space and traffic. West needed a second sorting line, so the East station moved there and East designed one for its own space. The report also records that a custodian had little time to monitor sorting at lunch once periodic monitoring tapered off.
The tension is between keeping enough separate collection steps to recover materials and making those steps fit the space, time and staff available at lunch. If the design is hard to use during peak traffic, students may miss a return step and reusable utensils may be lost. If staff have time to support a layout suited to the room, the separate streams have a better chance of working as intended. These are mechanisms to test. The relocation documents a practical constraint, not the size of any effect on sorting.
Check the claim. Did the new stations reduce sorting errors?
The case study says the team dropped its plan to track weights for trash, compost and recycling. It documents how the schools adapted the strategy, but it does not establish a change in the proportion of incorrectly sorted items due to the stations. To test that narrower question, compare like lunch periods, retain the number of items observed in each period and record any differences in monitoring or setup.
In your own strategy discussion, connect a documented decision to the perspectives behind it and explain what could change in the environmental or societal outcome. Identify the evidence that could test your explanation. The IB explains this link between perspectives and outcomes in its ESS curriculum update for first assessment in 2026.
Evaluate the local conclusion
Answer the measured question within the site's conditions and the sampling limitations. Explain how a practical improvement could address the most important weakness. Relate the findings and perspective evidence to the chosen strategy without promising an outcome the investigation did not establish. Review the current ESS guide with your teacher, then leave time for revision and the school's final submission checks.
Your next-step checklist
Checklist choices stay in this browser.
Official references
The recycling counts are original simulated teaching data. The strategy exercise draws on the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency’s published case study. Use the IB guide and your school’s instructions for your assessment session.

