IB History IA example: claims and counterevidence
Use a short History IA example to test an argument against a public primary source, integrate counterevidence and keep claims within the evidence.

State a provisional answer first
Before drafting a History investigation, write a provisional answer to the research question and identify its limits. This gives the draft an argument to test. It should remain open to revision as evidence develops. Then break the answer into a few supporting claims. Each claim needs a reason and source support. A chronological narrative can provide context, but chronology alone does not establish a judgment about cause, effect or significance.
Build paragraph evidence packets
For each planned paragraph, collect the claim, relevant evidence, interpretive link and strongest complication. Include precise references in your working notes. The complication may be contrary evidence, a different interpretation or a source limitation that reduces confidence. Do not force every paragraph into identical lengths or symmetrical sides. The structure should follow the historical problem and the weight of evidence, with each paragraph advancing the answer.
A History IA example: revise an overbroad claim
A short primary-source exercise can show exactly how counterevidence changes an argument. Here the issue is the extent of women's parliamentary voting eligibility after the British reform of 1918. The task is to test one claim, not to explain the whole suffrage movement.
Open the primary-source extract
Read the UK Parliament-hosted extract from the Representation of the People Act 1918 ↗. It reproduces section 4, including women's parliamentary and local-government voting qualifications. This is a selected extract, not the full Act.
Document date: 6 February 1918. Location: the extract's single PDF page, section 4(1)(a) and 4(1)(c). Section 4(1) concerns parliamentary constituencies other than university constituencies; section 4(2) deals separately with universities.
Practice claim to challenge
The 1918 reform gave every woman aged 21 or over the parliamentary vote.
1. Check the age condition
Section 4(1)(a) sets the qualifying age at 30.
Effect on the claim: this directly challenges the proposed inclusion of all women aged 21–29. A general statement that women gained the vote leaves out a consequential restriction.
2. Check the further qualification
Section 4(1)(c) adds a condition involving local-government electoral qualification through occupation of specified property, or a qualifying husband.
Effect on the claim: age alone was not sufficient under this provision. Avoid reducing the wording to a rule that every woman had to own property personally.
A narrower claim supported by these clauses
The reform extended parliamentary voting eligibility to qualifying women aged 30 or over, while retaining exclusions. This provision therefore supports an argument about an extension with limits, rather than universal eligibility for adult women.
This is a small revision demonstration. An investigation must still define its question, establish context, examine further evidence and justify its wider judgment.
Evaluate this source for this particular use
- Value: a precise record of the enacted qualification
- The Act's legislative origin makes its wording directly relevant to a claim about the formal rules introduced. The explicit conditions let you correct the draft without guessing at an author's private intentions.
- Limit: eligibility does not measure participation
- This extract does not show how many eligible women registered or voted, nor which groups encountered practical barriers. Electoral registers or suitable participation records would address a different part of that inquiry.
- Limit: the outcome does not establish its cause
- The provision alone cannot determine how much wartime service, earlier campaigning or political calculation contributed to the reform. A causal argument needs relevant evidence of the decision-making process, not an assumed motive added to the legal text.
What changed in the argument? The counterevidence overturns the word every and changes the age claim. It does not justify the opposite exaggeration that the reform changed nothing. Both clauses belong to one document, so they are not two independent sources corroborating each other.
Try this on your draft: choose one sentence containing all, only or because. Identify the precise evidence it needs. Record whether your source supports that sentence, narrows it or answers a different question, then decide what further evidence would matter.
Integrate counterevidence honestly
Place counterevidence where it affects the relevant claim. Explain whether it overturns the claim, narrows it or requires a different causal account. A separate objections paragraph is not automatically necessary. Avoid weakening your answer through ritual phrases about every source being biased. Specific evaluation shows why particular evidence should receive particular weight. You can reach a reasoned judgment despite uncertainty, provided the judgment's scope matches what the evidence establishes.
To record why your provisional claim changed, work through a dated research checkpoint that separates a public statement, a reported outcome and another plausible influence.
Reverse-outline the investigation
After drafting, summarize each paragraph in one sentence. Read those sentences together and check that they form a coherent answer. Remove repeated context, revise unsupported claims and ensure the conclusion follows from the analysis. Confirm the required structure and other submission requirements for your History cohort with your teacher. A strong investigation is traceable: the reader can follow how particular evidence supports a claim and how competing evidence changes the final judgment.
Check the evidence trail before you finish
Choose one important sentence from your response and trace it back to the source or class material that supports it. Check whether you have stated an observation, inferred a cause or adopted another historian's interpretation. Those claims need different kinds of justification. Record precise references in research notes and separate quotations from your own paraphrases. Then ask what evidence could weaken the sentence and whether your answer acknowledges that possibility. This short audit improves the relationship between evidence and argument without requiring you to add more material simply for length. When accounts disagree, check whether they refer to the same period, population and outcome before deciding that one contradicts the other. This comparison can reveal a difference in scope that a simple reliability judgment would miss.
Your next-step checklist
Checklist choices stay in this browser.
Official references and historical evidence
The IB sources establish cohort-specific assessment requirements. The Parliament-hosted extract supplies the historical evidence used in the reading exercise. The diagnosis and revision are original IBvia teaching suggestions; they do not imply an awarded grade or IB endorsement.

