How to refine an Extended Essay research question
A focused question gives you a manageable investigation. Identify what you will examine, how you will examine it, and whether the available evidence can support more than a summary. Then revise the question alongside your research plan.

Separate your interest from your question
“Responsibility in Frankenstein” names an interest. It does not yet tell you which feature of the novel to analyse or what your investigation will try to establish.
Write two sentences before drafting the question: “I want to understand…” and “I could investigate this by…”. For an English A essay, the second sentence should describe a literary approach, such as comparing narrative perspectives. A discussion of whether scientific invention is morally acceptable would take the same novel in a different disciplinary direction.
The IB requires a research question framed as a question, rather than a hypothesis or statement of intent. It should invite analysis and remain manageable within the EE’s 4,000-word limit.1
- 1. Name the interestResponsibility in Frankenstein: a topic, not yet an investigation.
- 2. Set the boundaryWhose account? Which technique? Choose a text, focus and method.
- 3. Test the evidenceFind passages and alternative readings. Can they sustain an argument?
- 4. Revise and test againKeep, narrow or change direction. Update the plan with the question.
Choose a useful boundary
Adding a date or a character’s name does not automatically improve a question. The boundary should tell you which evidence belongs in the investigation and which material can be left out.
| Version | Question | What still needs testing? |
|---|---|---|
| Too open | How does Shelley present responsibility in Frankenstein? | “Responsibility” could cover many relationships and techniques. |
| More focused | How do Victor’s and the creature’s accounts shape judgments of responsibility for violence? | Which passages, which edition, and what features of narration? |
| Working question | How does Shelley use retrospective narration in Victor’s and the creature’s accounts to complicate responsibility for violence in the 1818 Frankenstein? | Does the evidence support “complicate”, or has the question already decided the answer? |
The final version is a proposal to investigate, not a model answer. If your reading cannot support its assumptions, change it. Keep one edition consistent and discuss the literary focus with your supervisor.
Define words that carry the argument. In this example, distinguish responsibility for an action from responsibility for its consequences, and decide what you mean by retrospective narration. These definitions guide your passage selection; they should not become a detached dictionary exercise.
Test the evidence before polishing the wording
Make a small evidence map. For this example, locate passages where Victor recounts his response to creation and where the creature describes rejection. Note who is speaking, what is being explained, and which narrative choices might affect your interpretation. Record exact locations from your own edition.
Then look for resistance to your first reading. Does a passage undermine a speaker’s explanation? Does Walton’s framing change how you understand the accounts? Read relevant criticism and distinguish a critic’s argument from your interpretation of the novel.
You are checking whether a sustained argument is possible. A list of scenes involving blame is useful preparation, but the essay would still need to explain how narration creates meaning.
Follow a worked revision
Suppose your reading supports a comparison of self-justification but not a wider claim about responsibility for violence. A possible revision is:
How does Shelley use retrospective narration to develop contrasting forms of self-justification in Victor’s and the creature’s accounts in the 1818 Frankenstein?
The revised wording still needs testing. Compare passages that support your reading with passages that complicate it. A more specific sentence is useful only if it leads to a better investigation.
Consider a competing explanation
Write two plausible answers to the question. Ask what evidence could make one more convincing than the other. If neither answer could change, you may be assembling confirmation rather than testing an interpretation. This check works differently across subjects: competing literary readings are not the same as competing explanations for an economic trend.
Keep the essay aligned with the question
Any substantive change needs a fresh evidence test. It also changes the plan: define self-justification, select passages that reveal it, consider competing interpretations, and remove sections that no longer answer the question. Do not keep the old essay underneath a new title.
The IB explicitly allows a research question to change as research develops or suitable resources prove insufficient.1 Keep a brief record of what changed, why, and what you will do next. Discuss meaningful changes with your supervisor.
Your next-step checklist
Checklist choices stay in this browser.
Common questions
Must I begin with “To what extent”?
No opening phrase does the analytical work for you. Choose wording that fits your investigation; then test the evidence and method.
Can a narrower question become too narrow?
Yes. If it produces only an obvious answer or leaves little to analyse, reconsider the focus. Specificity is useful when it makes a worthwhile investigation possible.
Should I change the question after drafting?
Possibly. Compare the question with the argument you can actually support. Discuss the change, then revise all affected sections rather than changing only the cover page.
Official references
The worked example and diagram are original IBvia teaching material, not a student case study, an examiner endorsement or a promised route to a grade. Your subject guidance and school instructions determine the requirements.
- IB Extended essay guide: first assessment 2027 ↗ — see printed pages 84–86 for research-question development and consult the relevant subject guidance.
- IB: DP extended essay updates ↗ — confirms first assessment in May 2027.
- IB Extended essay guide for sessions before May 2027 ↗ — use the version that applies to your session.

